I just found out today how truly difficult Chemical Engineering is. And this is just the start. It all started when I was assigned to design a functional and practical chemical plant to produce benzoic acid on an industrial scale. Doesn’t sound that hard huh?
Well, let me tell you exactly what I am supposed to do:
Describe the chemical product i.e. benzoic acid in detail from properties chemically to physically to history.
Describe applications and uses of the product.
Perform a market assessment locally, nationally and globally and also possible future outlook.
Perform a detailed site study to state where chemical plant will be located and built and detailed and logical reasons why the place has been chosen. Sites are from real places located in Malaysia.
Design several process out of scratch to produce benzoic acid ideally 2-3 different and distinct processes.
Propose a process that can successfully produce benzoic acid on an industrial scale.
- Perform detailed calculations to calculate flow rates and amount of raw materials required over a span of time to produce exactly 50,000 metric tons of benzoic acid per year.
- Calculate mass transfers, energy balances and flow rates of materials within reactors in the process.
- If necessary, add additional equipments such as heat exchangers, distillation columns, reactors, boilers, separators, settlers, condensers, pumps etc.
- Calculate temperature, pressure and other conditions for each reactor.
- Calculate volume and size of each equipment used within the process.
- Calculate power consumed for each and every equipment in the process.
- Design mechanical equipments for major reactors.
- Design equipment to purify benzoic acid product at the end of the process to meet industry standards.
- Design equipment for treatment of by-products for recirculation, sale or waste.
- Recheck whole process for any flaws that may cause production to halt during process.
Perform hazard study for each and every line in the process for every potential and possible accident or incident that can cause the process to halt.
If any hazards found and deemed very dangerous, modify process flow above to increase safety.
Perform environmental studies around the area and potential impacts in the local areas surrounding the plant.
Design and decide on plant layout of each and every equipment on plant site.
Perform a detailed and current economic analysis for the plant which includes:
- Number of engineers that are hired to operate the plant efficiently.
- Number of skilled laborers to operate the plant’s equipments.
- Number of unskilled workers required for non-technical areas of the plant i.e. cleaning.
- Number administrative officers and workers required to administer the plant.
- Total cost of raw materials.
- Total power and water consumption of the entire plant.
- Current price of benzoic acid in the market.
- Calculate the estimated profit of the plant annually. (If process is deemed unprofitable, start design of the plant from square one)
- Transport costs of product and by-products for sale and distribution.
- Total estimate maintenance cost.
- Total cost for every worker’s salary.
State a conclusion and state recommendations.
Present entire research design for assessment.
There, this is what I and 4 other group members are supposed to perform and complete within 3 weeks before my final examinations. Since this project took off, it really hit hard on me that Chemical Engineering will and always be not an easy thing to do.
Well, I guess I can use this excuse to control my spending of money and outings that aren’t necessary since I need to save as much as possible for my studies in the UK.








hie… i’m a chemical engineering students too at University of Malaya, Malaysia… i juz accidentally came across at ur page n guess what? can u help me becoz i’m also is assigned to write a report on benzoic acid but not as detail as yours…
can u help me?
Guang: It really depends on what am I suppose to help you with. It’s more than a year ago. I might not be able to remember everything I did.
Comment by eezwana — 15 August 2007 @ 8:37 pm
hehe… i tot there will be no answer.. tq very much… anyway, we need to design a reactor for benzoic acid n d problem is… we need to know how is actually the reaction rate, suitable catalyst n etc… becoz dis subject is about reaction… i have msn account n can u add me??? eez_86street@hotmail.com.
From there we can chat n easier for me to ask question…. tq guang!=)
Guang: Unfortunately, I am not able to help you because what you are doing and what I did is totally different.
You are designing a batch chemical reactor, I designed a continuous chemical process. I don’t have a chemical reactor to specifically produce benzoic acid by batch. We don’t calculate reaction rates, catalysts etc. We have distillation columns and flash drums not a chemical reactor.
I’m really sorry. I am of no help to you.
Comment by eezwana — 9 September 2007 @ 12:07 am
o0o…okies…tq very much anyway…=)
Comment by eezwana — 12 September 2007 @ 3:33 am
Hi Guang, I am James from Toronto Canada also studying Chem Eng! Nice to meet you chem-brother. It’s good to know there are other chem engineers out there struggling hehhe.. Sounds like that project was very heavy, I can feel the weight just by reading it.
I was browsing around for information on a plant design project - benzoic acid production, and it is very much like what you described. I was hoping you could give me a little help if you don’t mind. Please reply.
Guang: Hey, chem-bro. I’m afraid that I might not be able to help you as time is against me this year. Workload is piling up faster than I can complete them. This is why that I’ve not replied your comment for such a long time.
I’m really sorry dude.
Comment by james — 17 September 2007 @ 3:34 am
Hey, thanks for replying, yea school is really piling up here too. I know you are busy, it’s ok. I don’t want to take away any of your time just to help me out. Bus I was wondering if you could maybe let me see your report and get some ideas from it, I am sure that would give me a jump start.
hope you could use email if you reply or maybe add me to msn? maybe some day you will need my help
… we are both chem engineers I’m sure we can related.
ok, thanks again. ttyl
James.
Comment by james — 6 October 2007 @ 5:52 pm
Hi,
Do any of you know how much Benzoic acid costs? I run a company that is developing a process that may require large amounts.
Regards
Scott.
Guang: Hello Scott. To be honest with you, all the commentators above including me are students. We are in no position to give you any information especially the current price of benzoic acid.
If you and your company needs current prices of chemicals why don’t you just call up a supplier and ask for a quote since you are going to need it anyway. I’m no manager of a company but being a student this would be the most logical thing to do. I’m pretty surprised I would say.
Comment by Scott — 11 February 2008 @ 8:34 pm
Hi there, came across your article while surfing the net. Really enjoy reading this article as I’ve been through the exact situation during my 4th year. It’s really a nightmare but I’m glad I can be trained like that. Just wondering which university you are studying in. Hope you are doing well and all the best.
Guang: Hey. Thanks a lot! I’m now at The University of Sheffield, UK.
Comment by Sue — 26 June 2008 @ 2:41 pm